The response of The Four Seasons [as the group 'brand'] and Frankie Valli [the 'solo' artist] to the rise of Motown, Psych-Pop and Rock and their reaction to the Sgt Pepper album and the 'Summer of Love' was somewhat contrived, in a world in turmoil in 1968. Bob Crewe was distracted with his group of companies and his roster of artists. Bob Gaudio had been taking greater control but was still feeling he had to change.
“Rock N Roll - year by year”, by Crampton and Rees says of 1968....”A revolution seemed entirely possible. The world was fraught with violent protests and scarred by political assassinations. The Summer Of Love gave way to violence, alienation and student unrest.”
Social comment in music had been bubbling for a few years and particularly in America. Bob Gaudio had been exploring new directions at The Bitter End in Greenwich Village and liked Jake Holmes social lyrics. The germ of a totally unique album in the groups history started there in 1966 with Bob and by 1968 he and Jake Holmes would start writing together. It took them 6 months to write the actual tracks they wanted. Bob ‘sold’ the group and Philips on a NEW sound for the Four Seasons and a big investment of time and effort went into its arrangement and production.
Bob Gaudio wanted to be different and wanted the public to see and accept what he said about where he was as a songwriter and producer ,"I'm getting a little tired of hearing people say 'why don't you be what you used to be'" said Gaudio on 25th January 1969 in Cashbox. "We're not what we used to be. We're not making records like 'Sherry' anymore. You must grow up. How can you be what you were 7 years ago. If you are, you are in a lot of trouble'"
He would never move from such thinking as the future story will demonstrate, but he would be locked into the same 'chord progressions' as would be seen in his ultimate success of the 1970s. But at the time this was The Four Seasons as never before....or since.
The first song of his move to change sounds, 'Saturday's Father' was a sad story of a ‘Fathers Day’ [it’s original session song title we believe] and a man meeting his children ‘every Saturday’ after a marriage break up. Bob Gaudio was certainly changing the lyrics but the song featured the usual strong harmonies. It would get release on PHILIPS 40542 on June 3rd 1968 and did not create much of a sales success. It reached #101 on the Billboard Chart, and the group returned to the studio as the tracks from recording sessions in September 1968 were being prepared for an album.
But during those recording sessions they separately turned to Petrillo-Linzer for a different style ‘Four Seasons’ song with a barely intelligible lyric perhaps related to psychedelia. With a ‘ blow your mind’ lyric, 'Electric Stories' was a driving beat single [Philips 40577] in a November release. It was a Crewe-Gaudio production, arranged by Charlie Calello, and according to him there was optimism it would achieve chart success. It received airplay in both the US and UK. B/w 'Pity [from 1966's 'Working My Way Back to You' album] and released on 19th November 1968 the 'A' side achieved # 68 on the Billboard Chart. Changing the sound and keeping the fans buying their records was clearly a problem but still it made the Hot 100.
The album that followed from the second half of 1968 sessions didn’t surface until January 1969 as the ''Genuine Imitation Life Gazette' Philips 600-290 was to fans ‘quite stunning: in looks and in music’
The group, always known for joyous harmonies and romantic boy/girl songs, had moved so far away from such songs to a social commentary and a cryptic look at society in both the complex songs and the huge artwork to the gatefold album and magazine. The album sleeve came out in the format of a six page newspaper-like print with an 8 page supplement. The 'like a daily newspaper' insert was a surreal mixture of wire service stories and creative news and lyrics printed as mainly irreverent news stories. A combination of satire, parody, political consciousness and irony coupled with sham and illusion. A commentary challenging reality and truth. Moreover, the songs reflected the mirror of life in all aspects. Bob Crewe was not involved although Charlie Calello did contribute and is credited on piano.
As well as the album release in January 1969 a juke-box EP/ mini LP was released with 5 tracks.
Donald A. Guarisco says the album, "lives up to its reputation as the most bizarre album in the Four Seasons' catalog", describing it as "a concept album that casts a satirical eye on American life." He calls it "relentlessly inventive, skillfully constructed, and never dull" and "a stunning example of the artistry of the Four Seasons at their most ambitious."
Was this the style of a modern group in 1969?
After $100,000 investment by Philips in the product and promotion, results were disappointing [reached a disappointing Nr 68 in the album chart, arriving some 18 months after Sgt Pepper...and without anything like the same effect] and whilst the group and Frankie performed superbly, Bob Gaudio would later accept it was a move too far. Whether he was trying to match The Beatles and the Beach Boys or get an 'underground' or ‘POP’ hit with such a different sound only he could confirm. Neither market responded but more significantly Philips would lose faith in the group. Whilst acclaimed by some critics and fans for its ground-breaking approach it remains for some the Four Seasons equivalent of the Beach Boys 'Smile' album. It was an experimental work and like ‘Smile’ it has it’s ‘dedicated followers’ and was the vinyl insert Snapper Music chose for the anthology Box Set issued in 2023. Radio programmers at the time were apparently as confused as the record buying public.
Bob Gaudio put it succinctly in a 2002 interview with Ken Sharp in Goldmine magazine: "One of the disappointments of our career for me on a creative level was the ‘Genuine Imitation Life Gazette’ album. It was just something that I had to do at that time. It got wonderful reviews, but obviously it was not an acceptable piece from us. Everybody was expecting Top 40."
Bob Gaudio's lyrics on the title track perhaps sum up his move away from the groups roots...... 'Chameleon’s changing colours, While a crocodile cries, People rubbing elbows, But never touching eyes, Taking off their masks, Revealing still another guise, genuine, imitation life...."
Fans either loved it or hated it with such comment as.....'I find it really hard to explain, but this whole album feels musically like someone doing a boring pastiche of the Beach Boys' baroque era stuff, but it has the tone of the terrible song 'Student Demonstration Time' from 'Surfs Up'. Like a person who doesn't have anything to say trying to say something while ‘eschewing’ being controversial.”
But a balanced view of this significant moment in their clear fall from grace with many long-standing fans is worth noting as one who commented at the time......."The first time I heard 1969's "The Genuine Imitation Life Gazette" I just scratched my head in wonder. Musically and thematically it reflected an obvious, if bizarre and belated "Sgt. Pepper" influence (the inner sleeve even includes a 'cynical parody' Beatles cartoon image). As such the collection found The Four Seasons desperately trying to stake out an updated, hip and 'happenin' sound in an effort to hold on to a rapidly declining audience. Reportedly one of the year's most expensive production efforts, exemplified by material such as 'American Crucifixion Resurrection', 'Saturday's Father' and 'Soul of a Woman' the band's stab at conceptual pieces of social commentary were well meaning, if inept. They certainly didn't waste any time taking on the width and breadth of American society. Racism ('American Crucifixion Resurrection'), the evils of gossip ('Mrs. Stately's Garden'), broken families ('Saturday's Father') and insincerity ('Genuine Imitation Life') were all fair game for commentary. To be fair, Valli and company couldn't be criticised for their dedication to the project. Songs like 'Father's Day' [Saturdays Father](complete with sound effects), the droning title track, and the single 'Idaho' (sounding like The Beach Boys overdosed on laxatives), made it clear they'd spent a lot of time, effort and their label's money on the album. Unfortunately the results literally dripped with ill-directed sincerity and over-the-top excess. There was plenty of blame to go around, but I would start by pointing the finger at Jake Holmes and Bob Gaudio in their roles as principal songwriters. With the exception of the bouncy 'Mrs. Stately's Garden', 'Somethings On Her Mind' and 'Wonder What You'll Be' these songs were so different from the patented Four Seasons sound you, that you almost had to feel sorry for fans who stumbled into it. Add to that, few of these tunes had the patented Four Seasons commercial edge fans expected. All those critiques and cheap shots aside, with the benefit of hindsight the album was entertaining in a strange and demented fashion. There was just something fascinating in hearing Valli's [faded] falsetto trying to belt out deep and significant lyrics like 'American Crucifixion Resurrection' as the title track. But using the same closing fade out with.....'nah-nah-nah-nah....nah-nah-nah-nah -- nah-nah-nah....play it cool' as a 'lift’ from 'Hey Jude' was a pretty 'crass' act"
Bob Gaudio in interview in 1971 said that he thought it was their best ever album but no-one accepted at the time that any established group's could change, that is he said "apart from The Beatles - as the only group that was allowed to grow up!", whilst Frankie Valli said he was never happy telling people the type of social criticism lyrics that were in several of the songs. He would however go onto sing songs of deep personal pain in the future years of his career, as I will cover.
Needless to say, the album proved a major commercial disappointment. Peaking at # 85 and the band's collective disappointment led, it has been suggested, to a brief falling out between Gaudio and longtime producer/co-writer Bob Crewe. The question.....'Has Bob Gaudio killed the Four Seasons Sound?'....seemed a valid question at this time. Today every fan of the group have their own opinion of it’s quality as a ‘piece of artwork’. It is widely regarded as a masterful piece of artwork in terms of both its innovative packaging and its complex music, though it was a commercial failure when first released. Over time, it has evolved from a misunderstood career anomaly into a celebrated cult masterpiece of the psychedelic era.
Even as ‘Genuine Imitation Life Gazette’ [GILG] was being prepared for issue and promotion at the end of 1968, Frankie Valli's solo career and the SOUND of the Four Seasons was lost in a ‘music market’ now dominated by changing sounds. With the sense of 'revolution', riots and assassinations in the USA and the progressive rock sound of The Beatles latter days, the music was more adult and serious with The Rolling Stones now becoming pop icons too. The days of 'Flower Power' had gone. Martin Luther King was murdered, Nixon was in power and album sales of various artists hit an all-time peak in that year.
Everything in terms of the whole group's talents was going into Bob Gaudio's concept of the GILG sessions in the second half of 1968 and with their failures in the singles market was being matched by the failure of the 'Timeless' album [# 167 on Billboard] so there was little focus and direction in the group or Frankie Valli's recording direction. Although 'Timeless' made #62 and #73 on Record World and Cashbox album charts respectively, this was a long way short of their HIT era. The ‘Session Master’ Philips paper records for this period show them clearly losing faith and the group and Valli were struggling to find good 'commercial' songs or songs Philips would consider for release.
Tracks were being recorded and left ‘in the can’ as this Tape Box scan shows from our trawl of the FSP storage archive.
'You've Got Your Troubles' saw release with little success. They had been working with Artie Schroeck and with Charles Calello in an effort to find a sound and a hit for Frankie Valli but this slow version of The Fortunes song was perhaps an ‘echo’ of where they were.
Bob Crewe with Artie Schroeck and George Schowerer at Mirasound Studio – Photo courtesy of George Schowerer – Sound Engineer
Further 45 releases of two GILG tracks 'Idaho' [#95 on Billboard but higher on Cashbox #64 and Record World #72] and 'Somethings On Her Mind' [Billboard #98] also saw little success in early 1969. Philips lack of faith led to SOLO efforts by Frankie Valli on Bob Crewe's own CGC label of 'The Girl I'll Never Know' and the failed film theme song 'A Dream Of Kings'. Although both superb songs and productions and arrangements, they saw poor sales. Philips had stopped promoting them and basically lost faith in them and they didn’t have any chance of selling their studio efforts.
'A Dream Of Kings' was a song from the movie of the same name. The film was first shown on 15th December 1969 but did not feature the song. However, it was featured on the soundtrack LP on National General NG 1000 released in February 1970. A 'Special Mix' single version was released eventually by Philips [40661] as a 'B' side in January 1970 and the STEREO version first appeared on ACE CD 635 [ 24th June 1996], described by Bob Gaudio as a 'big mistake' in interview it remains a very little known but superb Frankie Valli vocal.
Similarly, 'A Face Without A Name' was equally another superb Frankie Valli vocal of a Crewe-Gaudio song recorded at the March 1969 sessions. It really is a forgotten gem. It was first recorded in November 1968 but that STEREO Master [2-42858] has been lost in tape storage. The second MONO Master [1- 44773] was released by Philips on 40622 in May 1969 as the 'B' side to 'The Girl I'll Never Know' [which did quite badly given previous releases and only achieved # 52 on Billboard but #23 on Record World and #28 on Cashbox]. Interestingly, Philips 40622 was also issued on a 33⅓ rpm 4″ flexi-disc by ‘Americom’ [Philips 40622P] in 1969 with play times of 3:30 for each track.
A late 60s recording session of a group trying to find a new sound
However, they still had a contract deal, and dispute would arise by 1970 with Philips over the lack of releases and promotion. The distraction of Frank Sinatra's 'Watertown' album for Bob Gaudio and Bob Crewe's financial and addiction issues meant the group was really lost, with little direction or identity. Frankie Valli was still 'the voice'. However with Tommy DeVito's debt issues [which is believed to have emerged during this period] it meant an all-time low, creatively and financially.
BUT Philips, not prepared to miss out on the huge back catalogue made sure they raked in the money on the issue of Bob Crewe's STEREO double album of the 1960s hits [‘Edizione D'Oro’ - #38 on Billboard but slightly lower on Record World #40 and Cashbox #41] It meant some light at the end of the tunnel. Fans out there may not have heard these latest recordings but they remembered the HITS and now they had STEREO record players for the first time.
‘Edizione D'Oro’ remains a 'milestone' release whilst at first appearance it contained nothing 'new' focusing on the past successes of the Four Seasons. Philips wanted something to cash in on and saw the very strong development of the STEREO album market at this time as the opportunity. The album came at a time when Philips and the remainder of the US record industry was switching to an all stereo catalogue, basically eliminating MONO on the album format. Lou Simon, Product Manager at Philips estimated that in the 3 years before 1968 the Four Seasons had sold 5 million albums. They asked Bob Crewe for the Four Seasons Masters in the 'best' STEREO versions for a major STEREO market targeted release. This was easier said than done. The multi-track Masters did not exist as 3 track tapes in many cases and Bob searched through the 'mixes' that still existed from the sessions in STEREO to find the best. There is even a recording of his search on 17th September 1968 that you can hear by clicking this link. Bob discovered 'PREVIOUSLY UNHEARD' STEREO MIXES or ALTERNATE versions that make this a very significant and highly valued album in what was to be a high quality pressing of a 2 album - 29 track 'Gold Edition'. Although the double album was allocated a single record number, in true Philips labelling tradition. The first LP was actually numbered PHS600283 and the second was designated PHS600284. It was released in its full vinyl format for the first time on CD in 2023. [A previous issue in 1997 by ACE used a mix of MONO and STEREO versions due to contract issues with the Four Seasons Partnership.] These debut STEREO mixes are what warrants the album such a high status 'compilation' rating compared to previous 'Gold Hits' sets. The double album was packaged with beautiful glossy, gold-full, matt finished, golden coloured sleeve variations and came with a free 1969 astrological chart.
The relative success of a return to the classic hit group sound with 'And That Reminds Me b/w The Singles Game' [a #45 hit on the Billboard Chart but scoring higher on Record World # 27 and Cashbox #33] on Bob Crewe's own label [Crewe 333] in mid 1969, also meant Philips were prepared to give them another chance and they commissioned an album under their existing contract.
But 1970 was beckoning and "the roller-coaster 1960s were over. By comparison 1970 felt like a cold shower - a year laced with tragedy in which music fragmented into sub-genres" according to Crampton and Reece in ‘Rock & Roll -- Year By Year’. Joplin and Hendrix were soon gone, the Beatles era had ended, Diana Ross left The Supremes, The Doors declined with the emergence of Elton John and The Jackson Five. Art rock, soft rock, funk, and early punk began carving out separate audiences and identities away from mainstream psychedelic pop.
Even in such changing times, the success of 'And That Reminds Me' persuaded Philips to think again and to invest, but this time it was not in an album for The Four Seasons, or one for Frankie Valli but in an album shared by 'both', titled 'Half And Half'. The last two years of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons stay at Philips were fraught and somewhat confusing. As Paul Urbahns rightly observed...."Coming off the disastrous effort (sales wise) of the '....Life Gazette' album, it looks like Bob Crewe was struggling and Bob Gaudio probably didn't have enough tracks by the 4 Seasons for a new album but by mixing Frankie Valli solo material with the Four Seasons material they could 'assemble' an album". Joe Long has also indicated this situation existed. It was a lower risk project for Philips as both Valli and the group had such a catalogue reputation.
Back tracking through a set of diverse songs from the previous 2/3 years they revisited songs with high quality arrangers and productions. The mixture of arrangers contributed including Charles Calello, Bob Scott and Bob Gaudio. Notwithstanding Bob Crewe's business and addiction problems he recorded, mixed and supplied the album to Philips, with Bob Gaudio's help. The album was Mastered on 25th March 1970 and supplied to the Four Seasons Partnership Archive [in both MONO and STEREO] for Philips to release in April. This album [only released in STEREO at the time - and in MONO for the first time in 2023] again had an impressive artwork 'gatefold’ cover. It featured an embossed sleeve with colour photos of the group inside with Frankie Valli on the front cover.
Songs were tested out 'live' in concert as distinctly different in style and David Cace recalls, specifically, two cuts from that album heard in concert. “The 'Any Day Now/Oh Happy Day 'combination was first performed live during the 4 Seasons performances at the Empire Room at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel in NY in December of 1969. The audience reception was positive, the group liked it, and they recorded it for the album. It continued to be performed in concert throughout 1970 with Tommy DeVito and continued into 1971 with Demetri Callas in the group as his replacement. Regarding 'Circles in the Sand', it was mentioned during concerts beginning in March of 1970 as Frankie's next single. The single release has a closing ending instead of the phase out ending compared to the album version. The recorded version however is no match to Frankie's live performance of the song which was simply stunning, especially the ending where he lets it "all hang out" as the expression that was used back in the day. I don't remember Frankie closing a song with so much emotion since he used to sing 'My Mother's Eyes' in concert. Bob Gaudio was the live back-up voice accompanying Frankie in concert instead of the recording which has Frankie's voice double tracked. The audience loved it and it remained in the live act through the summer of 1970." That may have been why Philips made the strange decision to put the 1967 recording of 'My Mother's Eyes' on the B side of 'Circles In The Sand' [Philips 40680 in May 1970]
The album came out in April 1970, however a distressing sales result achieving only #190 Billboard album chart placing (#102 on Record World) accompanied a Four Seasons single release failure of # 94 Billboard (but #53 Cashbox and #56 on Record World) spot for the superb 'Patch Of Blue/She Gives Me Light' [original alternative title 'The Light'] in the same month.
This led to a decision that they and Philips needed to part company even though tracks were being collected and produced for another album provisionally titled '1970'. Any faith Philips had in Frankie Valli or The Four Seasons was disappearing fast. Their career was at, perhaps, its lowest ebb. Would they, like other groups that year, collapse completely?
The final Philips recording sessions resulted in a mixed bunch of styles as the group sought a new direction and sound.
Other productions remain unheard from the Philips/Mercury archive transfers from 16 track reels and need further research. Three tape scans of songs transferred to 16 track in January 1971 as the group prepared to leave Philips are particularly telling. We have been told most are 'simply instrumental backing tracks'.....a comment that was never proved.
One of 3 tapes that exists has ‘track 27’ which Frankie Valli announced as their next single during a concert and 4 of the other tracks would be found complete and included in the Snapper Music Box Set. So why copy backing tracks onto 16 track master tapes from the Philips archive if they are incomplete? You will understand my suspicions as these tapes were not transferred to the ‘Research Team’
However the final days of Philips produced an almost inspiring experimental style with two of the best and rarest singles for years.
'Heartaches and Raindrops' [Master 2-47439] was the 'B' side of the Four Seasons penultimate single in September 1970. The 'A' side of that release 'Lay Me Down, Wake Me Up' Philips 40688 was edited from a lengthy Bob Crewe session with a solid rock styling from the analogue STEREO Master Tape running 6 min 11 seconds. The Tape actually listed the song as an alternative title 'Let This Time'.[working title - see above tape scan] A promo variation is "Bob Crewe Presents Special Advanced Copy of Philips Records of 'Lay Me Down' (mono/stereo 45) by THE FOUR SEASONS” {with no Philips logo or black centre dividing line on the label} It first appeared in a full length STEREO CD version on Rhino Rarities Vol 2 CD R2 - 70974 in 1990
The failure of the superb Sandy Linzer song arranged by Charles Calello, 'Where Are My Dreams' [Philips 40694] released in November,1970 would prove to be the 'last straw' for the group with Philips lack of radio promotion and the groups final 45 release at the label was surprisingly released in both MONO and STEREO [DJP 74 single] The single did reach # 112 on the Record World charts. It appeared as 'Where Are My Dreams/Any Day Now-Oh Happy Day' (still as The 4 Seasons) on Philips 40694 and also as 'Where Are My Dreams' (mono/stereo) promo Philips DJP-74 ending the Philips recording era.....with a wimper!!
But at the same time, Bob Crewe was on the verge of a 'breakdown' and the Crewe-Gaudio writing relationship would collapse but not before Crewe would co-write 'A New Beginning' with Bob Gaudio. It would take Bob Crewe two years plus to recover and for that song to appear. It was recorded as a country-rock styled demo possibly by the group 'Light' based on a possible/probable demo vocal by Bob Gaudio. You can hear it here.
Another strange happening was a session of instrumental tracks by the group being recorded after they left Philips and stored ‘unheard’ for 49 years, which seemed so out of context being in a country-rock style never visited before or since in the studio.
Click the image to hear these tracks
Track 13 is interesting as it is the arrangement and backing track to the ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water/ McArther Park/Long and Winding Road’ ‘medley’ that they performed LIVE through to 1974 in their LIVE Concerts. The LIVE vocal version can be found in the Snapper Music Box Set.
Billboard reported on 19th June 1970 that Crewe Productions including CGC and Maxwell Records had filed for bankruptcy in the NY Federal Courts with debts of nearly half a million dollars with Crewe Publications also with $700K of debts and no cash in hand. Bob Gaudio was ‘flirting’ his money with his own [unsuccessful] Gazette Record Label with the folk rock group 'Lux'/'Light' [- which included Bob Grimm, who would soon become a Four Season]. Six sides appeared before this label folded. By far the best song and production was 'Happy People' with old writer buddy Mike Petrillo with the group - Lock, Stock and Barrel - on the Gazette label.
But in an amazing change of fortune the UK beckoned, via a cult music scene that was identified as 'Northern Soul' by Dave Godin, who imported and distributed rare soulful singles from the mid to late 60s for his record shops in Manchester and London. With the rise of a new dance club genre, which was developing within North England all-night clubs like The Twisted Wheel in Manchester in 1969, [and the off-shore UK pirate Radio Stations playlists]. This led to Philips UK re-releasing 'You're Ready Now' in response to demand that 'bootlegging' was responding too with a rogue re-issue. It was an amazing success as it became a dance floor classic achieving a #11 chart placing in the UK Charts in December 1970.
A Tour was quickly organised [the first for 8 years] and they arrived in the UK - but without Tommy DeVito. Bob Grimm was his replacement. Bob says of this time....."Prior to joining the Four Seasons, I felt very close to Bob Gaudio. We had great talks; I found him very intelligent and a natural leader. His energies were boundless. He generally beat me at chess! After entering the group, my closest friend and ally was Ricky Centalonza, the alto sax player in our back-up group."
The first date was at Torquay's Princess Theatre on 21st of January 1971. This was quickly followed by a session at Morgan Sound Studios [an independent recording studio in Willesden in North West London, founded in 1967] and on 26th and 27th, a planned 45 release was recorded to cash in on the success of 'You're Ready Now' with ‘rock focused’ songs. A surprise signing with Warner Bros UK would in time follow as this was really an oddball recording session that produced 3 completed tracks. ['I Just Can't Help Believing' would also be laid down and be unreleased until 2023]
Tour Dates followed at Stockton Fiesta Club (cabaret club) on 1st to 3rd of February followed by concerts in Ireland and Paris for 4th to 6th but at unknown venues. UK Tour dates resumed at:-
This quickly arranged 1971 UK/Europe tour generated much needed income and popularity and they appeared on BBC ‘Top Of The Pops’ - unusually for 'non-chart appearing' artists.
So of Bob Grimm, who had been recruited by Bob Gaudio from the folk-rock group 'Light' [Lux'].......Of his recruitment he said...."I went to Bob with my tail between my legs and told him of the group's disbanding. He was disappointed but seemed to have interest in my career and offered me a job as back up guitarist with the Seasons. At the time, I had no idea I'd be taking Tommy's place!"
There were several reasons quoted as to why Tommy Devito had left the group and why Grimm came in. Mike Derrico summed up the rumours....."I've heard many reasons as to why he initially left...one of which was that he didn't like to fly and didn't want to go to England again. Another reason I've heard is that he had just undergone surgery. Of course, the other one is over money...things that the [Jersey Boys] musical subtly touches on." But one fact related, which needs to be considered is that he may not have been able to leave the USA after the revelation of the debt he incurred and which Frankie and Bob picked up. He was effectively in 'financially' controlled 'custody'{sic} in Las Vegas, along with his mafia ‘friends’
The Tour Programme was now an 'oldies styled' concert as the contract with Philips and releases was terminating. The Show programme reflected this as shown by Bob Grimm's confirmation of the songs performed at the Fiesta Club, Sheffield, England, January 1971:
The London BBC TV Top Of the Pops performance on 25th February included "Let's Hang On" and "I've Got You Under My Skin" . John Riley who had recently joined a newly emerged UK Appreciation Society said of that exciting time for UK fans....."Thanks to 'You're Ready Now', I saw them for the first time at the Odeon in Manchester. I had expected them to avoid the falsetto, hardly believing that such a voice was possible without trickery in the studio, but they absolutely 'ran after it'. Frankie's voice was superb, Joe Long was the friendly spokesman on stage and off and the group musically were tight. Not only that, but new things like the 'Bridge Over Troubled Water' medley and 'Any Day Now/Oh Happy Day' were a revelation. It was magnificent and over far too soon."
Bob Grimm again....."After recording in London, [and playing on the recorded tracks] I received an offer from the folks at Morgan Studios to do a solo project. At the same time, I learned that I was to be replaced by my friend Demetri Callas. Things just seemed to work out in a timely fashion. I was sort of expecting it as Joe[Long] made no effort to hide his dislike for me. In all fairness to Joe, I was a kind of big-mouth in those days! I hold no malice! Also-THE HAIR!!" Joe was clearly not happy with Bob as a new member and he stayed in the UK and met a girl and became a father there. Bob Grimm again :-“I met lots of stars in the recording business and decided that some of them were really nice folks. I shall not cast aspersions on the assholes; the world now knows who most of them are!"......"Frankie and Bobbie are both gentlemen and always treated me well. Joe, as I've indicated, never liked me. I'm grateful for the fifteen minutes of fame the Four Seasons gave me. It was a great time to be in the music business and opened many doors."
The success of that UK Tour led to another visit in September 1971 after the release on the 3rd, of the rock styled 'Whatever You Say b/w Sleeping Man' with Kinney Music. The resultant release [ Warner Bros K 16107] from their earlier tour recording was to become their rarest ever recording. This single clearly missed the 'plot' [being the wrong beat and style for Northern Soul club scene] and was a big mistake but an interesting 'rock' production and strangely it also came out in New Zealand, but was never performed LIVE.
They arrived again in U.K. on 5th September 1971 with the following dates booked.
The tour was really just a cabaret club tour but with good venues such as the Sheffield Fiesta which had opened in August 1971 with a 1300 seat amphitheater. In its hey-day it headlined major US acts and would see such stars as Roy Orbison and The Beach Boys and the Four Tops in its short life.
They departed the UK on 4th October and surprisingly there was no London venue with this tour. The group had been booked in to play at 'The Talk of the Town' night club in Soho but the spot was already filled by Lovelace Watkins. The club suggested a date early in the following year. However the group then considered performing at the Bumpers Night Club in Piccadilly Circus instead but scrapped the idea due to pressure from Talk of the Town management and the nearby localities of the two night clubs.
After the UK tour and return to the USA on 4th October, news broke of a NEW label for the group in the USA based in LA.
The dedication of UK fans had started and began to grow and they were still seen as a 'hit group' in the UK and their tours had established the group's identity and European popularity and another UK tour was planned. The UK Fan club was up and running and the rarity of the group's work as they entered the 70s cannot be over-stated. It became so bad that there was a desperate need in the then recently formed fan club for fans of their 60s music to hear their rare and unavailable recordings. Then President, Stuart Miller organised a 50 pressing bootleg album of their rarest tracks from the recent Philips et al labels. The Bootleg UK FAN CLUB ALBUM Much Camp and High Falsetto Productions MCHF 55 would emerge in April 1973 with the following titles:
But that was still to come as in 1971 the group were performing wherever and whenever they could as they sought to pay off the debts from Tommy's gambling, and the hoped for success was still a promise and they needed a Record Label contract. Success after their ‘popularity’ in the UK/Europe was in sight – surely – unless a new label would fail them as Philips did. So with high hopes it was back to the USA.